The bags are back: Coronavirus health concerns and cheap oil fuel plastic comeback

The bags are back: Coronavirus health concerns and cheap oil fuel plastic comeback

April 30, 2020
Amber Schultz

Amber Schultz from Crikey takes a look at the resurgence of the once-dreaded product and asks whether our switch back to plastic could be permanent.

The KeepCup has fallen. Once-fashionable re-usable shopping bags are now something of a faux pas. And on the streets, disposable takeaway containers spill out of overflowing yellow bins.

COVID-19 has caused plastic to make a comeback in a big way across the world. Health concerns have fueled demand for single-use plastic, and negative oil prices mean producing plastic is cheaper than ever before.

Bans of plastic bags and single-use bottles have been suspended across the USA and India. The UK has reversed guidelines limiting the production of plastic. In Australia, there’s been a surge in home-delivered groceries and packaged takeaway meals, while the World Health Organisation has called for a 40% increase in the manufacturing of disposable personal protective equipment.

Paul Harvey, a research scientist at Environmental Science Solutions, believes there has been been a shift in people’s attitudes to plastic. “People’s attention is moving away from environmental matters to health-conscious,” he noted.

From travel-sized bottles of hand sanitizer to facemasks that contain plastic vinyl composites, Harvey believes the public is becoming accustomed to single-use plastics. “In the short term, I suspect there’ll be an increase in the demand from products made from plastic as we go back to normal. People will feel more comfortable having things in a perceived cleaner environment than taking their own shopping bags or re-usable cups,” he says.

In the long term, there’s a concern these habits could stick. “It may become a mindset and a way of life. People are going to become reliant on single-use plastics as they previously were.”

Plastic is incredibly cheap to make, which is why it’s so popular among manufacturers, Dr Stuart Thickett, a polymer chemist and senior lecturer at the University of Tasmania suggested. “Plastic is manufactured from crude oil. While most crude oil is used to make fuel, some of it is refined and processed to extract the material needed to make polymers – in other words, plastic.”

As the price of oil continues to plummet into negative numbers in recent weeks, so too does the price of manufacturing plastic. “Making commodity plastics is pretty cheap, especially compared to other ways of making plastics from biodegradable materials to renewables,” Thickett said.

“People are going to jump on the fact crude oil prices are really low.” Low oil prices make virgin plastic cheaper than recycled plastic, meaning there’s no incentive for recycling systems to operate.

Meanwhile, online department store purchases are up 473%, while fashion purchases are up 203%. Many textiles, including polyester, contain plastic.

“There’s a big push to do away with re-usables and a pushback toward single-use stuff, but plastics carry coronavirus on their surface as well, so as long as re-usables are cleaned properly there’s not any reason why single-use plastics are better,” Thickett explained.

Of course, he added, when it comes to hospital and personal protective equipment, “there’s always a place for single-use plastic”.

It’s not all doom and gloom, according to Sabrina Chakori, a PhD candidate at the University of Queensland. In fact, COVID-19 might actually decrease plastic used in food transport and production. Chakori’s research analyzes how economic degrowth and post-growth will affect packaging food systems. “Since the last global financial crisis, we started seeing more packaged food and pre-cut vegetables, which responded to the demand for convenience and people being time-poor,” she said.

Low-income and high-income groups both buy packaged food, but for different reasons.

“Some people in low-income situations can’t afford fresh food, but people with high income have limited time, so also prefer convenience package food.

“Time is a big variable,” Chakori continued.

During a lockdown, time is endless. “People have more time to cook, so may move away from manufactured food,” she added.

Another factor affecting food packaging is the supply chain; the longer food has to travel to arrive in supermarkets, the more plastic is used.

Australians spend 10% of their household food bills on imported food, but export bans introduced by international governments, combined with closed factories, could see some international items disappear from supermarket shelves.

“People might start to consume more local products to help stimulate local economic growth,” Chakori said.

The lesson? While plastic has been embraced once again in even the most eco-conscious suburbs, it might not be permanent. So long as you wash your re-usables thoroughly, and avoid plastic unless necessary, it doesn’t have to be a permanent fixture in our day-to-day lives.

This article was first published by Crikey. Amber has been a reporter for The Age, writer for ABC Comedy’s Tonightly, and creator of student talk show The Struggle. She was awarded the Jacoby-Walkley scholarship in 2018, and was an associate producer at Nine News

The rescheduled Plastic Free World Conference & Expo 2020 will take place at Cologne Messe, Germany, on Monday 9 November and Tuesday 10 November. To register for this highly focused, solutions-driven event, please click here. For sponsorship and exhibition opportunities, please email [email protected]